DIY Wills in Virginia: Why Signing Mistakes Can Cost Families Thousands

Vested Partners A Multi-Family Office Blog

Think a DIY will is the easiest way to handle your estate planning? Even one signature mistake could make it impossible to probate—leaving your family facing costly legal battles during an already difficult time.

It seems like the easiest thing in the world—sign your name, have a couple witnesses watch, and boom, you’ve got a will. What could possibly go wrong?

Turns out, quite a bit. And unfortunately, families don’t find out until it’s too late.

The Problem Nobody Sees Coming

As an estate planning attorney, I’ve watched this heartbreaking scene play out more times than you would expect. A grieving family walks into the Clerk of Court’s office with their loved one’s will, ready to start handling the estate. The clerk takes a look and explains that the will can’t be accepted without going before a judge because it wasn’t signed correctly.

Maybe the witnesses or notary signed in the wrong place.  Maybe there’s no notary seal. These seemingly minor details? They can sink the entire will.

What’s a Self-Proving Will Anyway?

Under Virginia Code § 64.2-452, you can make your will “self-proving” by having special language and a notary seal. You want  your will to be self-proving because it is a way to probate a will without jumping through a lot of hoops.

With a self-proving will, the clerk can accept it right away. Without one? Your family has to track down the people who watched you sign and get them to give sworn testimony about what happened.

When Your Witnesses Disappear

Here’s where things get really tricky. If your will isn’t self-proving, the witnesses have to be found to sign statements to confirm the will is legitimate.

But life happens. Your neighbor who witnessed your will moves to Arizona or dies. Your coworker retires to Florida. Time passes, and suddenly your family is playing detective, trying to track down people from five, ten, or fifteen years ago. Or maybe you took your will to the bank and had it witnessed and notarized there. If your family can’t find the witnesses, your will might be impossible to probate.

The Expensive Fix

When a will gets rejected by the clerk, your family needs to hire a lawyer to petition the Court for help. This means court filings, legal arguments, and at least one hearing. The cost? Often way more than hiring an attorney to do it right in the first place.

Smart People Make These Mistakes Too

Look, I get it. You’re perfectly capable of reading instructions and signing your name. But here’s the thing—there are legal requirements that aren’t always obvious, even to really careful people.

What We Actually Do

When you work with an estate planning attorney, we don’t just hand you papers to sign. We walk you through the whole signing process, provide the witnesses, make sure everyone signs in the right order, and make sure that every box gets checked.

It’s not about being complicated—it’s about making sure your will actually works when your family needs it.

Make It Easy for Your Family 

Don’t let your family deal with legal headaches while they’re grieving. Getting professional help now saves money, stress, and heartache later. Your family deserves a smooth process during an already difficult time.

Visit our website or call our office at (540)389-6060 to see how Robyn can help you make the estate planning process a breeze.

Legal Disclaimer. The information provided in this blog post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created by reading or interacting with this content. Laws vary by jurisdiction and individual circumstances differ, so you should consult with a qualified attorney in your area for advice specific to your situation.

Client Success Stories

Posted on Google
Amy Meacham
May 5, 2026.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Very professional and knowledgeable.
Posted on Google
Hunter Wimmer
March 27, 2026.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
[Financial folks have commented on how comprehensive and succinct my mom's estate package was. Her estate was settled in less than 4 months after her death] ... Robyn and her crew made this process incredibly easy. The documentation they drew up (will, trust, POA, and AMD) was very easy to understand as a layperson and very easy to execute — especially the will part (tip: have one person be the executor and trustee – and have them handle all of the personal effects/cars/jewelry. Robyn will explain). They were also available "after the sale" to help me through the process of settling the estate with very actionable and practical advice that saved me heartache and headache. They have a no-nonsense and very "real" way of constructing language that is clear and purposeful without the bloviated lawyer tone. On the flip side, my father in Florida paid half as much but I've had to pay other lawyers 20X as much to sort through the mess he left... and they can turn 12 words into 250 and charge you double for each vowel. Do it right the first time, because you don't get a do-over with this stuff. If you're looking for a comprehensive, simple, supportive estate-package, Robyn is the person to turn to. If you hate your kids and want to inflict pain after your death, prompting your kids to burn photos of you, I've got a guy in Vero Beach, FL you can call (rhymes with "dawn").
Posted on Google
Ann Hawley
February 19, 2026.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Having been unaccustomed to working with attorneys, I was a little apprehensive on my first meeting with Robyn Smith Ellis and her staff. They all made me very comfortable and at ease. Robyn was quick to understand the reason for my visit, and did some research we both could see on her big screen. She would need to obtain some information from the Courts before we meet again. I also needed to set up my will, POA and other estate papers. These were ready to peruse, make any necessary updates and sign at my next visit, along with the main reason for my initial visit. I would recommend Robyn Smith Ellis and her competent team for any need you may have, Elder law, family or business.
Posted on Google
Jeff Martin
February 6, 2026.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
I am very thankful to Vested Partners for helping me process my will. They were very kind and easy to work with! I would recommend them to anyone.
Posted on Google
Cris Flippen
October 17, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
My husband and I are very pleased with the services received from Robin Ellis and Vested Partners. Everything was very clear and all of our questions were answered in a personal and professional manner. We have a peace of mind that our adult children and grandchildren will have minimal issues settling our estate after our departures.
Posted on Google
LISA K. Taylor
August 29, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Robyn and her team at Vested Partners did an excellent job for us. We enjoyed working with them and would highly recommend her.
Posted on Google
Melissa Howell
April 17, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Robyn has been incredibly helpful in helping me deal with my wife’s estate. She helped me figure out whether or not to sue the hospital, and provided essential information that not only eased my anxiety, but helped me financially. I am very grateful to her and her firm. M. Howell
Posted on Google
Terri Hancock
April 1, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Robyn Ellis is a nice person to work with.She was very informative and she answered all of our questions and took time with us to do that. I definitely would recommend her.
Posted on Google
Sue Seaman
February 20, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Vested Partners was recommended to us by our daughter, We had no idea how to begin planning for our future, Robyn provided expert advice to help us decide what was best for our family. She and her staff were professional and worked to put our plan together in a timely manner and at a reasonable cost. Thank you for your support! The Seaman's

Join Our eNewsletter